All of Bach: a project by the Netherlands Bach Society
Prelude and fugue in E minor
An excellent piece for testing an organ, but maybe a touch too modern for the Arnstadt church council.
This piece originates from the time when Bach was still in his twenties. He had just got his first real job in Arnstadt. This position as a highly paid organist had fallen into his lap in 1703, after a brilliant performance when testing the new organ. But a couple of years later, it was actually criticism of his organ playing that was given as one of the reasons for letting him go. He was supposed to have used too many curious variationes and strange notes in his chorale preludes. The church council believed that this confused the congregation.
In this concise Prelude and fugue, we hear both sides of the coin. In the prelude, there are short pedal solos, shaking tremolos for both hands, and series of full chords for keyboard and pedal simultaneously – all exciting musical elements which can also be used, if necessary, to test an organ’s sound and speed of response.
These elements return in the fugue, which opens with a moving theme – first modestly and almost hesitantly, but later with increasing assurance. Towards the end, there is a passage where Bach makes the left hand stand out rather dissonantly against the right hand, in opposition to the rules of composition. This is precisely the sort of “frembde Thone” (strange notes) to which people later objected in Arnstadt. Here, we see a youthful and rather impetuous Bach. On the one hand, an excellent job application, and on the other a reason for dismissal.
- Prelude and fugue in E minor
- organ work
- ca. 1704-1709
- Special notes
- There is an even earlier version: BWV 533a.
Cast & Crew
|release date||29 April 2016|
|recording date||23 June 2013|
|Organ||Reil choir organ|
|FILM DIRECTORS||Jan Van den Bossche, Hanna Schreuders|
|CAMERA||Maarten van Rossem, Gijs Besseling|
|MUSIC PRODUCTION, EDITING AND MIX||Guido Tichelman|
|Film editor and interview||Gijs Besseling|
|sound interview||Kasper Koudenburg|